Publication Ethics

WIA Journal asks everyone involved — authors, reviewers and editors — to work honestly, give credit where it is due, and be open about how research was done, including any use of AI tools.

Principles we follow

Research integrity

  • Submit original, honest work.
  • Report methods and results accurately, including what did not work.
  • State the limitations of your study.
  • Cite every source you rely on.

Responsible authorship

  • List as authors only people who made a real intellectual contribution to the work.
  • Every author should have helped draft or critically revise the manuscript and approved the submitted version.
  • All authors share responsibility for the work as a whole.
  • Acknowledge other help (funding, technical support) separately.

Privacy and consent

  • Obtain informed consent where research involves people.
  • Remove or anonymise personal data before submission.
  • Follow the ethical approval rules that apply to you and your institution.
  • Treat communities and cultures in your research with respect.

Fair and open participation

  • Manuscripts may be written in any language (see Language Policy).
  • Submissions are judged on their content, not on the author's country, institution or language.
  • Reviewers and editors are asked to keep manuscripts confidential.

Use of AI tools

AI tools can help with analysis, language editing or drafting. We do not forbid them, but we ask that their use be transparent.

  • Disclose it. Describe in the manuscript (for example in the methods or acknowledgements) which AI tools you used and for what purpose.
  • Stay responsible. The human authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality and ethics of everything in the paper. An AI tool cannot be listed as an author.
  • Check the output. Verify facts, numbers and references that an AI tool produced; such tools can make mistakes or invent sources.
  • Protect data. Do not put confidential or personal data into tools that may store or share it.
  • Reviewers too. Reviewers should not upload a manuscript they are reviewing into outside AI services, because it is confidential.

See Citation Guidelines for a short note on mentioning AI tools in references.

Research misconduct

The following are not acceptable. If we find them, we may reject the submission or, after publication, correct or retract the paper.

Plagiarism

Using other people's text, data or ideas without proper credit — including copying without quotation marks, paraphrasing without citation, reusing your own earlier published text without saying so, and presenting AI-generated text as your own without disclosure.

Fabrication and falsification

Inventing data or results, manipulating analyses or images, or reporting only the data that support a desired conclusion.

Duplicate submission

Sending the same work to more than one journal at the same time, or republishing substantially the same study without disclosure and permission.

When you submit at /submit/, the final step asks you to confirm a declaration checklist covering points like these.

Conflicts of interest

A conflict of interest is anything that could reasonably be seen to affect judgement — financial interests, personal relationships, professional rivalry or institutional pressure.

  • Authors should declare funding sources and any relevant interests in the manuscript.
  • Reviewers should decline an assignment, or tell the editor, if they have a conflict with the authors or the work.
  • Editors should not handle manuscripts where they have a conflict.

Open access

Our intent is that work published in WIA Journal is freely readable by anyone, and publishing is free for authors. We encourage authors to share data and describe methods in enough detail for others to reproduce the work, where this is lawful and ethical.

Reporting a concern

If you believe a submission or published paper involves misconduct, an undisclosed conflict of interest, or another ethical problem, please write to the editorial office. Include the paper title or link and a clear description of the concern, with any evidence you have.

  1. Write to usSend your concern to help@wiajournal.com.
  2. We look into itThe editors review the concern and may ask the authors or others involved for an explanation.
  3. Fair hearingThe people concerned have the chance to respond before any decision is made.
  4. OutcomeDepending on what we find, actions may include no action, a correction, rejection or retraction.
We treat reports in confidence and ask that they be made in good faith.
↑