Participate in Peer Review

Peer review at WIA Journal is done by researchers who volunteer their expertise. Here is how it works on the site and how you can join.

How review works

  1. A manuscript is submittedAn author submits through the form at /submit/. The paper starts with the status "submitted". Authors may suggest reviewers, but the editor decides who is invited.
  2. An editor reads itAn editor looks at the submission and its fit for the journal.
  3. Reviewers are assignedThe editor assigns reviewers with knowledge of the field, and of the manuscript's language where possible.
  4. Reviewers give their assessmentEach reviewer sees the assignment in My reviews, reads the manuscript, and gives the editor a considered assessment.
  5. The editor decidesThe editor records a decision: accept, revision required, or reject. The final decision always rests with the editor.

What we ask of reviewers

Focus on the science

Assess the research question, methods, evidence and conclusions, and whether the paper adds to knowledge in its field.

Be constructive

Write comments that help the author improve the work. Be specific and courteous.

Keep it confidential

Do not share or use an unpublished manuscript for any purpose other than the review.

Declare conflicts

Tell the editor if you have a conflict of interest or lack the expertise for a paper, and decline the assignment if needed.

More detail is in our ethics policy and editorial principles.

How to volunteer

  1. Create an accountSign up at /auth/ and confirm your email address. Adding your affiliation and ORCID helps editors, though both are optional.
  2. Email the editorial officeWrite to help@wiajournal.com from the address you registered with. Tell us your field of expertise, the languages you can review in, and a little about your research background.
  3. Receive assignmentsOnce an editor assigns you a manuscript, it appears in My reviews.

Our reviewer pool is being formed now, so assignments may be occasional at first. Reviewing is voluntary, and you can decline any assignment.

Questions

Do I need to review in English?

No. Authors may submit in any language, so we welcome reviewers who can read manuscripts in other languages. Tell us which languages you work in.

Is reviewing paid?

No. Reviewing for WIA Journal is voluntary, just as publishing is free for authors.

Where do I find a manuscript I have been asked to review?

Log in and open My reviews. Your assignments are listed there.

↑